Is Cartesian dualism dead ?
نویسندگان
چکیده
For many, Cartesian dualism has lost the battle owing to the blows struck by the neurosciences and, in particular, functional cerebral imaging. In an article (Dualism Persists in the Science of the Mind)coauthored by Steven Laureys from the Coma Science Group at ULg, he reports on the conclusions of a vast survey he initiated: despite all, dualist conceptions still remain popular. Journey to the land of the "soul" and consciousness. Already in 1983, Jean-Pierre Changeux wrote in L'homme neuronal: "L'identité entre états mentaux et états physiologiques ou physicochimiques du cerveau s'impose en toute légitimité" (The identity between mental states and physiological or physicochemical states of the brain is definitely legitimate). Since then, studies based on functional cerebral imaging have increased and each one has added to the corroboration of this theory. In principle, Cartesian dualism is dead since everything indicates that the mind does not emanate from an immaterial substance outside the body. Modern science therefore joins forces with the materialist conceptions of the Enlightenment Philosophers. For Diderot and Baron d'Holbach, for instance, the mind is a property of the brain. And since, according to them, the latter obeys the laws of natural determinism, it cannot exist of its own free will. Hence, the belief in a free will must be slipped into the same coffin as spiritualism. In his Système de la nature, Baron d'Holbach writes: "Our life is a line that nature orders us to follow on the surface of the Earth without ever being able to stray from it for one moment."
منابع مشابه
Dualism and its importance for medicine.
Cartesian dualism has been viewed by medical theorists to be one of the chief causes of a reductionist/mechanistic treatment of the patient. Although I aver that Cartesian dualism is one culprit for the misapprehension of the genuine treatment of patients in terms of both mind and body, I argue that interactive dualism which stresses the interaction of mind and body is essential to treat patien...
متن کاملOn a Multiplicity: Deconstructing Cartesian Dualism Using Mathematical Tools in Performance
The well-known and seductive idea of being a dual entity composed of a body with emotions and a mind with reason, with only tentative and uncertain connections between them, has been considered an instrinsic human feature in many academic fields. Decartes’ (i.e., Cartesian) dualism, which associates reason with mental and rational processing and emotion with body and feelings has influenced tho...
متن کاملConsciousness and the Prospects for Substance Dualism
There has in recent years been a significant surge of interest in non-materialist accounts of the mind. Property dualists hold that all substances (concrete particulars that persist over time) are material, but mental properties are distinct from physical properties. Substance dualists maintain that the mind or person is a non-material substance. This article considers the prospects for substan...
متن کاملMind-Brain Problem and Consciousness
Dualism – The human brain and mind are separate. Known formally as Cartesian Dualism after it’s originator, the 17th century French philosopher René Descartes. Physical matter, including the body and brain, behaves according to the laws of nature, and is thus suitable for scientific investigation. The human mind (soul, self, or spirit), which controls human behavior, lacks physical substance--a...
متن کاملGood News, Your Soul Hasn’t Died Quite Yet
In this paper, I observe that Hobbesian physicalism on the one side, and Cartesian dualism on the other, have had a widespread cultural influence on the way we regard ourselves and on the way we behave toward one another. I argue that what we now need is a conceptual space within which we might forge a metaphysical alternative, an alternative that will give us some hope of overcoming the delete...
متن کامل